Original Article
Corneal Endothelial Cell Loss after Phacoemulsification with and
without Trypan Blue Assisted Staining of Anterior Lens Capsule
Arooj Amjad, Muhammad Shaheer, Ummarah
Rasheed
Pak J Ophthalmol 2017, Vol. 33, No. 4
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
See
end of article for authors
affiliations …..……………………….. Correspondence
to: Dr. Arooj Amjad Senior Registrar, Eye
Unit I, Lahore General Hospital/ Post Graduate Medical Institute, Lahore. Email: arooj.amjad@gmail.com |
Purpose: To study the mean loss of
corneal endothelial cell in patients undergoing cataract surgery with
phacoemulsification with and without trypan blue. Study Design: Randomized controlled trial. Place and Duration of Study: Institute
of Ophthalmology, Mayo Hospital/ King Edward Medical University, Lahore from
1-1-2016 to 30-5-2017. Material and Methods: All patients
diagnosed with cataract were selected for surgery. The patients were divided
into two groups A and B. Group A patients underwent phacoemulsification with
trypan blue aided central curvilinear capsulorhexis while Group B patients
underwent phacoemulsification without any aid of trypan blue. Patients with
any corneal opacity were excluded from study. Specular microscopy was done on
all patients before and three months after surgery. On specular microscopy,
corneal endothelial count, hexagonality and coefficient of variation were
noted. Specular microscopy and recording of findings was done by researcher. Results: A total of 152 patients
presenting to the Institute of Ophthalmology were included in study. Endothelial
cell loss was observed in both the groups but it was more in the Group A
(74.3421 ± 0.6332) as compared to the Group B (37.0658 ± 2.6891) (p 0.000). Conclusion: Phacoemulsification decreases
corneal endothelial cell count both with and without trypan blue. The decrease
in corneal endothelial cell count was more when phacoemulsification was done
with trypan blue but it did not lead to corneal decompensation. Key Words: Phacoemulsification, Trypan
Blue, Corneal Endothelial Cell Count. |
Cataract surgery is one of the most
frequently executed surgeries around the globe. In this surgery the opaque
cataractous lens is removed and is replaced by an artificial intraocular lens1.
The history of cataract surgery goes back two centuries where it started as
couching in this part of the world. Later on intracapsular cataract extraction2
was introduced which was refined to extracapsular cataract extraction3
in which the lens capsule was preserved. Phacoemulsification is the surgery of
choice now a days as it gives early visual recovery and patient rehabilitation
and minimal complications4,5,6.
Cornea is an important structure of the eye
which imparts about two thirds of the dioptric power to the eye. Due to this
the health and status of cornea assumes an important role when deciding for the
prognosis after any ocular surgery7. The state of the cornea is
mainly assessed by specular microscope8, 9, 10. It is well known
that anterior segment surgery11,12 results in a decrease in corneal
endothelial cell count and may lead to irreversible corneal compromise if the
condition of cornea is not healthy before surgery. Only very few studies are
present in literature evaluating the effects of trypan blue during
phacoemulsification on corneal endothelium.
Trypan blue is a vital
dye which is used in both anterior and posterior segment surgery. In vitreo
retinal surgery, trypan blue is used to stain the epiretinal membrane in cases
of macular pucker and proliferative diabetic retinopathy. While in the anterior
segment surgery trypan blue is mainly used to stain the anterior capsule in
mature or white cataracts in which visualization of capsule is difficult.
During staining of anterior lens capsule 0.2 ml of 0.18% trypan blue is
injected into the anterior chamber13,14,15. We undertook this study
to evaluate the effect of Trypan Blue on the corneal endothelium during
phacoemulsification.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A total of 152 patients presenting to the
Institute of Ophthalmology were included in study. Patients diagnosed with
cataract were selected for surgery. The patients were divided into two groups.
Group A patients underwent phacoemulsification with trypan blue 0.18% (RS BLUE
BY Alchimia) staining of the anterior capsule for central curvilinear
capsulorhexis while Group B patients underwent phacoemulsification without any
aid of trypan blue. Patients diagnosed with any coexisting corneal disease or
corneal opacity were excluded from the study.
All the patients underwent
phacoemulsification with intraocular lens implantation under local anesthesia.
HPMC 2% (Ocugel by Farmigea) was used during surgery to maintain anterior
chamber. After aseptic measures a corneal incision was made with keratome and
0.2 ml of 0.18% trypan blue was injected in anterior chamber of group A
patients for 30 seconds while no dye was injected in group B patients.
Afterwards a central curvilinear capsulorhexis was done and phacoemulsification
(Optikon Pulser 2) was done by divide and conquer technique followed by
implantation of intraocular lens. The corneal incision was hydrated and
antibiotic drops instilled into the eye. Dressing was applied at the end of
surgery. All the patients were prescribed a combination of steroid and
antibiotic drops post operatively. On the first post-operative day the patients
were discharged after slit lamp examination and called for follow up for
corneal endothelial cell count measurement.
All patients underwent
pre-operative and three month post-operative bilateral specular microscopy for
endothelial cell count, percentage of hexagonal cells and coefficient of
variation. Specular microscopy (SP-01 by CSO) was done by researcher and
findings were recorded. Wilcoxon signed ranks test was
applied for statistical analysis.
RESULTS
Out of 152 patients 83 were male (54.6%)
and 69 (45.4%) were female. In group A 42 (55.3%) patients were male and 34
(44.7%) patients were female while in group B 41 (53.9%) patients were male and
35 (46.1%) patients were female.
The mean pre-operative BCVA in the operated
eye was 0.92 ± 0.97. The mean post-operative BCVA in the operated eye was 0.096
± 0.127. The mean preoperative corneal endothelial cell count in the operated
eye was 2458.348 ± 72.382. The mean post-operative corneal endothelial cell
count in the operated eye was 2402.644 ± 77.431 (p o.ooo).
In
group A, Mean pre-operative BCVA of the operated eye was 0.91 ± 0.098. The mean
post-operative BCVA in the operated eye was 0.090 ± 0.127. The mean
pre-operative corneal endothelial cell count in the operated eye was 2443.315 ±
65.89. The mean post-operative corneal endothelial cell count in the
Table 1: Overall Visual Acuity and
Endothelial Count.
Sr. No. |
Parameter |
Operated Eye |
|
Pre-Operative |
Post-Operative |
||
1. |
Visual Acuity |
0.92 ±
0.97 |
0.096
± 0.127 |
2. |
Corneal Endothelial Cell Count |
2458.348
± 72.382 |
2402.644
± 77.431 |
Table 2: Visual Acuity and Endothelial
Count in Group A.
Sr. No. |
Parameter |
Operated Eye |
Difference |
|
Pre-Operative |
Post-Operative |
Post-Pre Operative |
||
1. |
Visual Acuity |
0.91 ±
0.098 |
0.090
± 0.127 |
0.010
± 0.8616 |
2. |
Corneal Endothelial Cell Count |
2443.315
± 65.89 |
2368.97
± 66.52 |
74.3421
± 0.6332 |
P 0.000
Table 3: Visual Acuity and Endothelial
Count in Group B.
Sr. No. |
Parameter |
Operated Eye |
Difference |
|
Pre-Operative |
Post-Operative |
Post-Pre-Operative |
||
1. |
Visual Acuity |
0.92 ±
0.096 |
0.10 ±
0.12 |
0.8263
± 0.0322 |
2. |
Corneal Endothelial Cell Count |
2473.381
± 75.81 |
2436.315
± 73.12 |
37.0658
± 2.6891 |
P 0.000
operated eye was 2368.97 ± 66.52. The
difference in visual acuity was 0.010 ± 0.8616 while the difference in
endothelial cell count was 74.3421 ± 0.6332 (p 0.000).
In group B, Mean
pre-operative visual acuity in the operated eye was 0.92 ± 0.096. The mean
post-operative visual acuity in the operated eye was 0.10 ± 0.12. The mean
pre-operative corneal endothelial cell count in the operated eye was 2473.381 ±
75.81. The mean post-operative corneal endothelial cell count in the operated
eye was 2436.315 ± 73.12. The difference in visual acuity was 0.8263 ± 0.0322
while the difference in endothelial cell count was 37.0658 ± 2.6891 (p 0.000).
DISCUSSION
It is well known through literature that
anterior and posterior segment surgery affects the corneal endothelium but no
local data is available is present about the effects of trypan blue on corneal
endothelium.
Our study shows that phacoemulsification
with intraocular lens implantation decreases corneal endothelial cell count
both with and without the use of adjunctive trypan blue. The authors compared
the corneal endothelial cell loss with and without trypan blue during
phacoemulsification and concluded that the corneal endothelial cell loss was
more when phacoemulsification was done with adjunctive trypan blue. Despite the
corneal endothelial cell loss no patient presented with corneal decompensation
on follow-up.
Dick HB et al16 studied corneal
endothelial cell loss after phacoemulsification in terms of incision size, per
operative phacoemulsification power used and surgery time. They found out that
the corneal endothelial cell count decreased more with increasing surgery time
and increasing ultrasound power. They concluded that 3.5 mm clear corneal
incisions resulted in a meager decreased endothelial cell loss as compared to a
5 mm incision.
Jerome R et al17 compared loss
of corneal endothelial cells after phacoemulsification using ultrasound or
fluid based system. They reported a corneal endothelial cell loss of 498±415 in
patients undergoing phacoemulsification with an ultrasound system, conversely,
the patients undergoing phacoemulsification with fluid based system showed
corneal endothelial cell loss of 302±302 cells. Thus, they concluded that
phacoemulsification with fluid based system results in a decreased corneal
insult.
Price MO et al18 studied loss of
corneal endothelial cell after two different techniques of Descemet’s stripping
endothelial keratoplasty. In their study, endothelial cell loss was less when
the graft was inserted through a clear corneal incision while it was more when
the graft was inserted through a scleral tunnel possibly due to more
compression during insertion.
Hengerer IC et al19 compared
corneal endothelial cell loss after femtosecond laser assisted
phacoemulsification and conventional phacoemulsification. They reported a
corneal endothelial cell loss of 7.9% after femtosecond laser assisted
phacoemulsification and a loss of 13.7% with conventional phacoemulsification.
They concluded that femtosecond laser assisted cataract surgery is a safer and
more advantageous method in terms of visual rehabilitation and patient comfort.
Chung CF et al20 compared trypan
blue and indocyanin green assisted anterior capsular staining during
phacoemulsification for white cataract. They reported no major differences in
phacoemulsification time and corneal endothelial cell loss in both the groups
as they were comparable.
Jacob S et al21
assessed the postoperative outcomes of phacoemulsification assisted with trypan
blue anterior capsule staining. They documented an endothelial cell loss of
8.5% in their study. Absence of local data on this topic was the rationale to
conduct this study.
CONCLUSION
Trypan blue assisted
phacoemulsification results in more corneal endothelial cell loss as compared
to conventional phacoemulsification but it does not result in corneal
decompensation. The authors feel the need of a large randomized controlled
study to have a bigger picture of the situation.
Author’s Affiliation
Dr. Arooj Amjad
FCPS, Senior Registrar
Eye Unit-II, Lahore
General Hospital
Dr. Muhammad Shaheer
FCPS, MRCSED,
Vitreoretina fellow
Senior Registrar
Eye Unit-III, Mayo
Hospital
Dr. Ummarah Rasheed
M Phill Statistics
Statistician, COAVS,
KEMU, Lahore
Role of authors
Dr. Arooj Amjad
Conception of research
IDEA, Writing of paper, Data collection
Dr. Muhammad Shaheer
Performing surgery,
Review of paper draft
Dr. Ummarah Rasheed
Statistical analysis
REFERENCES
1.
Mastropasqua
L, Toto L, Mastropasqua A, Vecchiarino L, Mastropasqua R, Pedrotti E, Nicola
MD.
Femtosecond laser versus manual clear corneal incision in cataract surgery.
Journal of refractive surgery, 2014; 30 (1): 27-33.
2.
Lomi N, Sharma R, Khokhar S, Dada T, Vanathi M, Agarwal T. Risk factors for intra operative complications during
phacoemulsification performed by residents. Int Ophthalmol. 2016; 36 (3): 401-6.
3.
Young AL, Jhangi V, Liang Y, Congdon N, Chow S, Wang F, Zhang X et
al. A survey of perceived training differences between ophthalmology
residents in Hong Kong and china. BMC Med Edu. 2015; 28 (15): 158.
4.
The Royal College of
Ophthalmologists. Cataract surgery Guidelines, 2010.
5.
Shah S, Peris-Martinez C, Reinhard T, Vinciguerra P. Visual outcomes after cataract surgery: Multifocal versus
monofocal intraocular lens. J Refract Surg. 2015; 31 (10): 658-66.
6.
Venkatesh R, Tan CSH, Sengupta S, Ravindaran RD, Krishnan KT,
Chang DF. Phacoemulsification versus small incision cataract surgery for
white cataract. Journal of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, 2010; 36 (11): 1849-1854.
7.
Memon MN, Siddiqui SN. Changes
in central corneal thickness and endothelial cell count following pediatric
cataract surgery. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2015; 25 (11): 807-10.
8.
Borego-Sanz L, Saenz-Francis F, Bermudez-Vallicela M,
Morales-Fernandez L, Martinez-de-la-Casa JM et al.
Agreement between central corneal thickness measured using pentacam, ultrasound
Pachymetry, specular microscopy and optic biometry lenstar LS 900 and the
influence of intra ocular pressure. Ophthalmologica. 2014; 231: 226-235.
9.
Monnereau C, Quilendrino R, Dapena I et al. Multicentre study of descmets membrane endothelial keratoplasty,
First case series of 18 surgeons. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2014; 132 (10): 1192-1198.
10.
Lee JWY, Chan JCH, Chang RT, Singh K, Liu CCL, Gangwani R, Wong
MOM, Lai JSM. Corneal changes after a single session of
selective laser trabeculoplasty for open angle glaucoma. Eye, 2014; 28: 47-52.
11.
Zoltan ZN, Agnes IT, Tamas F, Kinga K, Andrea G et al. Complications of femtosecond laser assisted cataract surgery.
Journal of cataract and refractive surgery, 2014; 40 (1): 20-28.
12.
Robin GA, Erica DS, Jeffrey BK, Penelope LA, Shawn YPE, Brenden
JV. Femtosecond laser assisted cataract surgery versus standard
phacoemulsification cataract surgery: Outcomes and safety in more than 4000
cases at a single centre. Journal of cataract and refractive surgery, 2015; 41 (1):
47-52.
13.
Hengerer FH, Dick HB, Kohnen T, Conrad-Hengerer
I. Assessment of intraoperative complications in
intumescent cataract surgery using 2 ophthalmic visco surgical devices and
trypan blue staining. Journal of cataract and refractive surgery, 2015; 41 (4):
714-718.
14.
Hamzaoglu EC, Straiko MD, Mayko ZM, Sales CS, Terry MA. The first 100 eyes of standardized descmets stripping automated
endothelial keratoplasty versus standard descmets membrane endothelial
keratoplasty. Ophthalmology. 2015; 122 (11): 2193-2199.
15.
Medsinge A, Nischel KK.
Pediatric cataract: challenges and future directions. Clin Ophthalmol. 2015; 9:
77-90.
16.
Dick HB, Kohnen T, Jacobi FK, Jacobi KW. Long term corneal endothelial cell loss after phacoemulsification
through a temporal clear corneal incision. Journal of Cataract and Refractive
Surgery, 1996; 22 (1): 63-71.
17.
Jerome R, Louis H, Ridings F, John C. Corneal
endothelial cell loss after cataract extraction by using ultrasound
phacoemulsification versus a fluid based system. Cornea, 2008; 27 (1): 17-21.
18.
Price MO, Price FW. Endothelial cell loss
after Descemet’s stripping with endothelial keratoplasty. Ophthalmology, 2008;
115 (5): 857-865.
19.
Hengerer IC, Juburi MA, Schultz T, Hengerer FH, Dick HB. Corneal endothelial cell loss and corneal thickness in
conventional compared with femtosecond laser assisted cataract surgery: three
month follow-up. Journal of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, 2013; 39 (9): 1307-1313.
20.
Chung CF, Liang CC, Lai JSM, Lo ESF, Lam DSC. Safety of trypan blue 1% and indocyanin green 0.5% in assisting
visualization of anterior capsule during phacoemulsification in mature
cataract. Journal of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, 2005; 31 (5): 938-942.
21.
Jacob S, Agarwal A, Agarwal A, Agarwal S, Chowdhary C, Chowdhary
R, Bagmar AA. Trypan blue as an adjunt for safe
phacoemulsification in eyes with white cataract. Journal of Cataract and
Refractive Surgery, 2002; 28 (10): 1819-1825.